Crop, resize or compress?
Cropping removes the edges and leaves the rest at its original size. If you want the whole picture at other dimensions, use the GIF resizer. If the picture is right but the file is too heavy, the GIF compressor lowers colors and frame rate. To play it faster or slower, use the GIF speed changer. And cutting off the first or last seconds isn't cropping at all: turn the GIF into a video with GIF to MP4, trim it with the video trimmer, and make a GIF again.
Watch one full loop before you crop
The box doesn't move, but the subject might. The GIF keeps playing under the box, so watch it once from start to end and check that a hand, a tail or a caption never leaves the frame. Leave a little more room on the side something moves toward.
Square first, then check the size
For custom emoji, crop to 1:1 and then check the app's limits: Slack emoji must be under 128 KB with at most 50 frames, and Discord's under 256 KB. Both are listed with their sources in our GIF size limits table. A square crop of a large GIF is usually still too many pixels, so finish with the GIF resizer at 128 px.
What a round crop looks like
A GIF pixel is either visible or not, with nothing in between. A round edge is therefore made of small steps. It looks smooth at larger sizes and on a background of a similar color, and slightly jagged when it's tiny. Keep a thin margin around the subject so the steps don't cut into it.